Religion in Modern America, 1865-1990
Jon Butler
Yale

This course traces the development, character, and im-pact of religion in modern America from the end of the Civil War to the immolation of David Koresh. The course does not stress "church his-tory," although religious institu-tions are important to it; rather, it em-phasizes interaction between America's many religions and emerging American modernity. Topics include the fate of "traditional" reli-gion in modern America; "alternate" American religious traditions; urbanization, in-dustrialism, and religion; sci-ence, technol-ogy, and secular-ism; evangel-icalism, mod-ernism, and fundamentalism; reli-gious bigotry; pluralism; religion and American foreign policy; and church and state. The course may be taken independently or in con-junction with its prede-cessor (AmSt 311-Hist 147-RelSt 293) which covers American religion from 1600 to 1865.

Lectures: I will lecture on Mondays and Wednesdays from 9 to 10:20; the lecture period ends with an opportunity for questions and discussion, and questions are welcomed during the lecture itself.

Discussion sections: Each student must sign up for a one discussion section and attend the section meeting each week; times and lo-ca-tions of the sections will be arranged during the first and second weeks of the course.

Grading: The course grade is determined as follows: a midterm examination will constitute 25% of the course grade; two short papers (1000 words each, due Feb. 1 and April 5) will constitute 10% each of the course grade; a grade for discussion section participation will constitute 25% of the course grade; and the final exam-ination will constitute 30% of the course grade. The proportion of the grade given for section participation will be raised when discussion section absenteeism is unusually high. Students may take the course on the Credit/Fail option.

Books:
Jon Butler & Harry S. Stout, Religion in American History: A Reader

Arnold Eisen, The Chosen People in America: A Study in Jewish Religious Ideology

Thomas J. Ferraro, ed., Catholic Lives, Contemporary America

William James, The Varieties of Religious Experience

Reinhold Niebuhr, Moral Man and Immoral Society

Ronald Numbers, Prophetess of Health: Ellen G. White and the Origins of Seventh-day Adventist Health Reform

Jill Watts, God, Harlem USA: The Father Divine Story

Lecture, Discussion and Reading Schedule

Week 1 How We Got Here: Religion in America, 1600-1860
Jan. 10: Course Introduction
Jan. 12: The Antebellum Spiritual Hothouse
Reading: Moore, "Insiders and Outsiders," in Butler/Stout

Week 2 The Life of the Soul in the Gilded Age
Jan. 17: Gendered Faith: Women & Religion in Post-Bellum America
Jan. 19: The Fall (and Rise) of "Alternate" Religions in America: The Cases of Spiritualism and Buddhism

Section: Prophecy and Reform in Post-bellum America: Numbers, Prophetess of Health

Week 3 Orthodoxies and Unorthodoxies in Late Nineteenth-century America
Jan. 24: The Spiritual Crises of the Gilded Age
Jan. 26: What William James Said: Paradoxes of Faith and Pluralism

Section: What is religion and what is a conversion? Reading: James, Varieties of Religious Experience, lectures 1-10

Week 4 The 80s: Religion, "Ruralization," and Urbanization
Jan. 31: Urbanization, Industrialization, & Modernization: Hydras of Decline?
Feb. 2: Immigrant Christianity: Protestants and Catholics in the New World

Section: What was the spiritual challenge of the city? Reading: *May, Protestant Churches and Industrial America, Part III, pp. 91-162; *brief selections from James King, Adolphus Schauffler, and Washington Gladden

Jan 31: Paper I due

Week 5 The 80s and 90s: American Pluralism Renewed
Feb. 7: The Rise of African-American Christianity, 1865-1900
Feb. 9: Recreating American Judaism

Section: What did religion mean to Du Bois? Reading: Watts, God Harlem USA; Montgomery, "The Preachers," in Butler/Stout

Week 6 Solutions for Heathen Souls and Heathen Societies
Feb. 14: New Thought, Christian Science, and the Social Gospel: Therapy for "Mind" and Society
Feb. 16: The Birth and Maturation of American Fundamentalism

Section: Whose Jesus would do what? Reading: *Walter Rauschenbusch, excerpt from Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907); *Mary Baker Eddy, excerpts from "Precept and Practice" (1902) and "Questions and Answers" (1896).*

Week 7 Religion and the American Indian

Feb. 21 Midterm Exam
Feb. 23: Bringing Christianity to the American Indian
Section: When is the "religious" the "secular"? Reading: DeMallie, "The Lakota Ghost Dance," in Butler/Stout

Week 8 The 10s and 20s: A Loss of Faith?
Feb. 28: The War to End all Wars and the American Spiritual Depression
Mar. 1: Inventing the Black Gospel Tradition, 1900-1950

Section: How do we take a decade's "spiritual temperature"? Reading: Handy, "The American Religious Depression," and Carpenter, "Fundamentalist Institutions," in Butler/Stout

Spring Recess, Mar.8-23

Week 9 The 30s: From Fundamentalism to the Holocaust
Mar. 20: Maturation of American "Fundamentalism"
Mar. 22: American Religious Bigotry and the "Abandonment of the Jews"

Section: Assess the impact of "America" on traditional religion. Eisen, The Chosen People in America

Week 10 The 30s & 40s: Transforming Modern American Religion
Mar. 27: Reinhold Niebuhr and the Crisis of Liberal Christianity
Mar. 29: "Protestant, Catholic, Jew" -- The State, Religion, and World War II

Section: What was "orthodox" about neo-orthodoxy? Niebuhr, Moral Man and Immoral Society

Week 11 The 50s: Therapeutic Theology, Civil Religion, and the problem of Justice
Apr. 3: "Positive Thinking" and the Profits of Therapeutic Theology
Apr. 5: Renewing American Religion: From Revivalism to the Supreme Court, 1940-1960

Section: Whose religion becomes "history"? Orsi, "Catholicism, Gender, and Modern Miracles," in Butler/Stout; Ferraro, Catholic Lives, Contemporary America, read four of the essays by Orsi, Allitt, Sullivan, and Weaver, and interviews with Paglia and Rodriguez

April 3: Paper II due

Week 12 The 60s & 70s: Religion and Politics Left and Right
Apr. 10: Civil Rights, Divine Rights, Women's Rights
Apr. 12: Conservative Protestant Re-Awakenings

Section: Religion and Society: What's Chasing What? Reading: Spillers, "Martin Luther King"; Johnson, "Jesus the Liberator"; U.S. Catholic Bishops, "A Pastoral Message"; Falwell, "The Imperative of Moral Involvement" in Butler/Stout

Week 13 The 80s and 90s: Born Again to What?
Apr. 17: From the New Age to the New Pluralism
Apr. 19: When Faith Goes Wrong: Jonestown, Waco, and the Pathologies of Belief

Section: When is religion "unhealthy?" Lawrence *Wright, "Remembering Satan," New Yorker, May 17, May 24, 1993*

Final Examination: Wednesday, May 3, 9-11 AM

Return to RSiSS Syllabi